Indigenous Thinking: What Makes Children Strong vs. Parental Rights
11/12/26
Because they are rooted in indigenous cultures, traditional Indigenous dispute resolution processes (a.k.a. “peacemaking,” “peace circles,” etc.) generally allow for indigenous thinking or worldview to operate more freely. Commonly noted benefits of indigenous processes include: (1) the solutions derived from them are more likely to “stick” or last long-term, (2) more people are allowed to bring their own opinions and abilities into development of, and carrying out, solutions developed to address problems, and (3) the process is more restorative or focused on healing.

As indigenous communities deliberate about how they might develop a modern-day system or infrastructure to formally support their own traditional dispute resolution processes, the topic of Indigenous worldview comes up. Indigenous languages and ways of life frequently reflect a very different worldview in comparison to the Euro-/Anglo-/U.S.A.-based colonial settler worldview that dominates how people are socialized in the U.S. and similar countries. Sometimes, what an indigenous worldview has to say offers great insights into ideas that are not as easily accessed from the worldview of settler descendants. A particularly insightful example, regarding child welfare, exists in the way the Oglala Sioux Tribe’s code for abused and neglected children (entitled “Wakanyeza na Tiwahe ta Woope”) (called “OST Code” from this point on) reframes what colonial settler legal systems define as “parental rights.”
Section 403 of the OST Code, entitled “Children’s and Family Rights,” Illustrates this distinction immediately: There is no subsection on parental rights. Having served on the drafting team alongside a panel of elders from across the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation, home of the Oglala Sioux Tribe, I can attest that this exclusion was intentional. Rather than defining parental rights, the code provides two distinct subsections using Lakota titles, accompanied by English translations for broader comprehension. But as I will show below, more literal translations of the Lakota language titles is very revealing of the indigenous thinking informing the subsections, however, much more so than the translations provided in the OST Code for the convenience of English speakers.
The first subsection is labelled “Wakanyeza Ta Wowasake (‘Traditional Children’s Rights’)” (italics added). The label in Lakota explains the traditional thinking behind the subsection. A more literal translation of the Lakota phrasing could be “What makes the Children Strong,” which captures how Lakota people view familial relationships and corresponding responsibilities. Because the formal legal concept of “rights” is non-traditional in many Indigenous cultures, the English terminology serves primarily as a bridge for English speakers. In Lakota tradition as reflected in Lakota language, the important consideration is what will make children strong, rather than identifying who can claim what “rights.” Then, when rights are used to provide an English explanation, the concept is somewhat flipped because now children are the ones who have a potential claim to make against others, and the parents (and other community adults) end up with obligation or responsibilities to the children. But perhaps that is a preferable perspective when considering child welfare, rather than establishing rights to children and parsing up subsidiary rights much like property, such as who gets to spend which portions of time throughout a year with a child. Better to view the whole endeavor as how to determine how to most benefit the children in their growth and development.
For the sake of completion, the subsection defines those “rights” of the children as follows:
(b) All children have a right to:
- a mother (Ina);
- a father (Ate);
- identify with the traditional way of life (Lakol wicoh’an);
- learn and speak his or her language (Lakol Iyapi);
- a family (Tiwahe na tiospaye);
- know their relatives (Wotakuye);
- know the traditional laws, customs, and ceremonies of the people; and
- live according to and to practice the traditional laws, customs, and ceremonies that govern the people.
Oglala Sioux Tribe, Wakanyeza na Tiwahe Ta Woope (Child and Family Code), Section 403.1(b) (italics added).
The other subsection addressing Children’s and Family Rights in the OST Code is labelled “Tiwahe na Tiospaye Ta Wowasake (‘Traditional Family Rights’)” (italics added). Similar to the section on children’s “rights” discussed above, a more literal translation of the Lakota title for this subsection could be “what makes families strong.” Lakota conceptualization of a family can include nuclear families living in the same home, and extended families, and the word for each of these concepts is included in the title. The subsection establishes the foundational role of family strength and healthy functioning in supporting child welfare:
(a) Largely because of their primary role in taking care of the children, tiwahe and tiospaye groups also have certain rights as set out in subsection (b). By definition, these rights are in the best interests of the tiwahe and tiospaye, and in turn they are therefore in the best interests of the children for whom the groups care.
(b) Tiwahe and tiospaye have a right, and corresponding responsibilities, to:
- Wicozani – to make choices and decisions to live a healthy and prosperous life according to the traditional laws, customs, and ceremonies;
- Igluhapi – to make choices and decisions to establish economic, political, educational and cultural self sufficiency, and to maintain privacy according to the traditional laws, customs, and ceremonies;
- Woope Gluhapi – to live and function according to the traditional laws, customs, and ceremonies; and to protect and nurture such laws, customs and ceremonies;
- Woitancan – to select and designate leaders to serve the people and to promote the common good according to the traditional laws, customs, and ceremonies; and
- Woilake – to select and designate such official officers and workers as the tiospaye deem necessary to serve the people and to promote the common good according to the traditional laws, customs, and ceremonies.
Oglala Sioux Tribe, Wakanyeza na Tiwahe Ta Woope (Child and Family Code), Section 403.2, Tiwahe na Tiospaye Ta Wowasake (“Traditional Family Rights”) (italics added).
This subsection encapsulates traditional values and processes that maintain healthy nuclear and extended families, recognizing that resilient family structures are vital to meeting children’s needs. The families are responsible to attempt to pursue these values and processes, in order to be strong and healthy so that they can meet the needs of the children as addressed in the previous section of the OST Code. And, importantly, others are expected to help the families function by supporting their proper functioning in alignment with the listed values and processes.
The OST Code effectively turns the notion of “rights” on its head, to reflect more of an indigenous worldview. While the term “rights” is used in translations of the subsection titles for the convenience of English speakers, what is really being defined are various responsibilities in light of what leads to healthy child development. The OST code actively transforms the law into one informed by and springing from Indigenous thinking, rather than the colonial settler worldview that dominates most United States law.
Hopefully this note has provided some deeper understanding on how indigenous worldview are different from the “norm” by which most of us in the United States and other similar countries are socialized. In so doing, it makes it more understandable why traditional indigenous dispute resolution processes like peacemaking, peace circles, and others are vital not only for Tribal nations’ seeking cultural revitalization, and also how they provide meaningful alternative perspectives for broader dispute resolution efforts worldwide.

